Massachusetts Medical Society: Testimony Relative to An Act Relative to Vaccinations and Public Health, and An Act Promoting Community Immunity Before The Joint Committee On Public Health

Testimony Relative to An Act Relative to Vaccinations and Public Health, and An Act Promoting Community Immunity Before The Joint Committee On Public Health

Testimony Relative to H.3999, An Act Relative to Vaccinations and Public Health, and S.2359/H.4096, An Act Promoting Community Immunity Before The Joint Committee On Public Health

The Massachusetts Medical Society (MMS) wishes to be recorded in support of House bill 3999, An Act Relative to Vaccinations and Public Health.

The MMS is a professional association of over 25,000 physicians, residents, and medical students across all clinical disciplines, organizations, and practice settings. The Medical Society is committed to advocating on behalf of patients, for a better health care system, and on behalf of physicians, to help them provide the best care possible. The Medical Society has long supported policy measures that strengthen public health. Vaccines are a critical public health tool that provide a safe and effective means to protect society from infectious and potentially deadly diseases. In fact, the World Health Organization listed vaccine hesitancy as one of the top ten biggest threats to global health in 2019. Over the past several decades, the public health of the Commonwealth has benefited greatly from the societal commitment to vaccination; however, in more recent years, vaccination rates have fallen, jeopardizing necessary herd immunity to preventable infection and disease that had been, until recently, effectively eradicated. The Medical Society opposes non-medical vaccination exemptions. It is for this reason that the Medical Society would like to voice its strong support for H.3999, An Act Relative to Vaccinations and Public Health.

In the interest of public health, and specifically the health of children in Massachusetts, state law requires children to be vaccinated prior to enrolling in school. The law, however, provides for two exceptions to this requirement—one medical and one non-medical (religious). H. 3999 would strike the non-medical (religious) exemption from the vaccination requirement, which currently allows parents or guardians who object to vaccinations on grounds of sincerely held religious beliefs to send their child to school without being vaccinated.

Although Massachusetts’ vaccination rate overall is among the highest in the country, certain districts in the state are experiencing exemption rates over 20 percent, which puts the entire Commonwealth’s herd immunity at risk, as outbreaks—even localized outbreaks—can overwhelm the broader population’s collective immunity. Distressingly, the recent measles outbreak in New York caused a public health emergency, despite a higher overall rate of vaccinated children entering school was than that in Massachusetts.

Over 80 percent of the vaccination exemptions in Massachusetts are based on a purported non-medical (religious) objection. For children entering school in Massachusetts, the non-medical (religious) exemptions rate has increased over seven times the rate seen just 26 years ago. As physicians, our role is to keep our patients and the public safe and healthy. Parents should feel comfortable voicing concerns or questions they have about vaccination and physicians should be prepared to listen and respond effectively and with empathy. It is imperative that we as physicians not only address vaccine misinformation with accepted science and data, but also share with well-intentioned parents the potential harmful and deadly clinical consequences that could arise if a child contracts a vaccine-preventable illness.

To that end, this bill would eliminate the non-medical exemption restore valuable public health protections by improving community immunity. Rather than acting reactively by waiting for a public health crisis to occur, the Medical Society urges the legislature to protect the health and safety of our children and our communities by proactively enacting a measure that will have a substantial public health impact. These diseases are preventable; vaccines are safe and effective. We must learn from the lessons in other states to address the issue in a prudent manner and strike the non-medical exemption from Massachusetts’ laws.

The Medical Society appreciates that the non-medical exemption is just one part of the broader immunization structure that exists in Massachusetts and that a comprehensive evaluation of related public policy is warranted to effectuate a thoughtful, comprehensive approach to immunization that is in the best interests of the public health of the Commonwealth. To that end, the Medical Society supports several proposals from S.2359/H.4096, An Act Promoting Community Immunity as outlined below. To be clear, the Medical Society opposes the provisions within S.2359/H.4096 that retain the non-medical (religious) exemption and instead supports the approach of H.3999 in striking this exemption altogether. However,

there are other provisions in S.2359/H.4096 that merit consideration and that we believe would strengthen the overall immunization public health system in Massachusetts.

One such proposal would standardize immunization schedules and the exemption review process. While the medical exemption has existed for years in Massachusetts—and the Medical Society supports its retention—it has evolved into a system that lacks standardization, a concern that would be exacerbated if the non-medical (religious) exemption is eliminated and additional strain is put on the medical exemption process. MMS therefore supports provisions in S.2359/H.4096 which create a standardized medical exemption form and which would centralize the processing of medical exemptions. MMS still believes that the decision to sign a medical exemption should be between a patient (and their parents or guardians) and a physician. The state should not be the arbiter of every signed medical exemption; however, processing such exemptions through the state, and allowing for review in exceptional circumstances, would benefit the medical exemption process.

Another important proposal in S.2359/H.4096 would compel important collection and monitoring of immunization data, as well as require public notification of the findings of this data. The collection of data and the standardization of immunization processes will serve the public health in myriad ways. For individuals who cannot be vaccinated due to medical conditions, mandating current and accurate information regarding vaccination rates in covered programs may be a lifesaving measure. For the Commonwealth as a whole, the data is important to track and inform efforts aimed at improving public health.

Lastly, the Medical Society urges consideration of provisions in S.2359/H.4096 that would explicitly add “preventive services” to the existing statutory list of medical services to which a minor—whose physician has determined is capable of making the decision—the right to consent. Pediatricians and other physicians who treat minors have long managed minors’ rights to consent to many different medical services. Adding to this list preventive services—which would include vaccines—would be a logical step in eliminating barriers for persons who want to be vaccinated—all with the protections that exist in any clinical encounter or assuring that a patient has the requisite capacity to understand the nature of a given medical decision.

Notably, these specific measures within S.2359/H.4096 are important to consider in a broader package, but are an insufficient remedy on their own and would do little to address the larger

problem of vaccine hesitancy, which the World Health Organization listed as one of the top ten biggest threats to global health in 2019. Instead, these measures would complement and strengthen the public health impact of repealing the non-medical exemption.

Thank you for your thoughtful and timely consideration of this issue. The Medical Society respectfully urges a favorable report on H.3999, An Act Relative to Vaccinations and Public Health.

Share on Facebook

Find Your Legislator

Click here to enter your address and get a list of your federal representatives, state legislators, and your local polling place.

Find Your Legislator »

State and Federal Agencies

State House - Mass. State AgenciesRapid access to relevant resources from State and Federal health care agencies for Massachusetts physicians.

Massachusetts State Agencies
Federal Agencies

Advocacy Videos

See our advocacy in action through videos and testimonials of physician-advocates! Advocacy video preview

Facebook logoTwitter logoLinkedInYouTube logoInstagram

Copyright © 2020. Massachusetts Medical Society, 860 Winter Street, Waltham Woods Corporate Center, Waltham, MA 02451-1411

(781) 893-4610 | (781) 893-3800 | Member Information Hotline: (800) 322-2303 x7311