Massachusetts Medical Society
MY MMS
Name:   
Password:   
Login help
 
 
Search
AboutJoin/RenewCalendarCareersContactSite Map
 
 
 
My MMS
Advocacy and Policy
Member Benefits and Services
Member Participation
Continuing Education
For Patients
Public Health
Physician Practice Resource Center
MMS Governance
Charitable Foundation
News and Publications
publishers of The New England Journal of Medicine
Massachusetts Medical Society
860 Winter Street
Waltham MA 02451
(800) 322-2303 or (781) 893-4610
© Copyright 2004



 
Massachusetts Patients Slowly Awaken to New Reality: Costly Liability Premiums Limit Access to Care

By Tom Walsh

Soaring Liability Rates: M.D.s and Patients in Peril

James C. K. Wang, M.D., OB-GYN, Westfield

Dr. Wang began practicing in Massachusetts in 1991 but has decided to stop delivering babies as of March 31. He described the decision as "an enormous struggle" because obstetrics is "a profession I love and have dedicated so much time and effort to learn."

Were he to continue as an OB-GYN, Dr. Wang's professional liability insurance would double for 2003 to $60,000. While he will stop practicing obstetrics, Dr. Wang said he will continue to practice gynecology, a specialty regarded as much less risky by insurance carriers and thus one that carries much lower insurance premiums.

Because of soaring insurance rates, Dr. Wang says he needs to "restructure and devise a new strategic plan for the survival of his practice."

Dr. Wang graduated in 1987 from the Tufts University School of Medicine and practices obstetrics and gynecology in Springfield and Westfield.

At first, there seemed to be no cause for alarm. On the Thursday after New Year's, 8-year-old Maggie Walsh was just a few doors away from her Holyoke home, sliding down a neighbor's small hill made slick with fresh snow. Only Maggie went a little too fast, hurtling over a snowbank and landing headfirst on the pavement. With a bad scrape above her eyebrow, Maggie walked the short distance home.

"She kept complaining that her head hurt," said her mom, Dianne Walsh. As afternoon became evening, Maggie asked her mom, "How did I get home?"

Dianne noticed her daughter's head was swelling on one side, and Maggie vomited soon after. Dianne called the family pediatrician who directed her to the emergency department.

A Bigger Shock Was Coming
Tests showed that Maggie had two skull fractures and severe cranial bleeding. But Dianne and her husband, Jeffrey Walsh, soon received a bigger shock.

"We assumed Maggie would be treated at the trauma center at Baystate Medical Center. I was panic stricken when we learned they were trying to get a helicopter to transport Maggie to Hartford," Jeffrey Walsh said.

Short staffed after recently losing two neurosurgeons, Baystate didn't have a specialist available to treat Maggie's injury, underscoring the looming crisis in patient access to care brought on by soaring medical liability insurance premiums. Already affecting Springfield and vicinity, obstetricians and neurosurgeons are in short supply there. And more physicians are considering whether to stop providing high-risk services, retire early or leave Massachusetts in search of a friendlier working environment. more

 
 
MassMed.org Home Vital Signs Home April 2003 Home Editorial Board Back Issues e-Newsletter Contact Us

Printer-Friendly Version
HOME SEARCH ABOUT JOIN/RENEW CALENDAR CAREERS CONTACT SITEMAP FEEDBACK
PRIVACY POLICY SITE CREDITS
 
 


Debugging Information
ColdFusion Server Standard 6,1,0,83762
Template /AM/Template.cfm
Time Stamp 25-Feb-05 02:37 PM
Locale English (US)
User Agent
Remote IP 10.1.1.35
Host Name 10.1.1.35


Execution Time

Total Time Avg Time Count Template
47 ms 47 ms 1 top level D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Template.cfm
31 ms 31 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\CM\HTMLDisplay.cfm
31 ms 31 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\TemplateBody.cfm
16 ms 16 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Templates\TemplateHeader\TemplateHeader.cfm
16 ms 16 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Templates\TemplateTopNav.cfm
15 ms 15 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Application.cfm
15 ms 15 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Ecommerce\BasketSetupTag.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\ApplicationCustom.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\ApplicationUDFs.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 2 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Common\CachedStoredProcTag.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\DetermineHeader.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\HierMenu\HierMenuTag.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\LoadSessionVariables.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\TemplateSection.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Templates\FooterInclude.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Templates\HeaderInclude.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Templates\TemplateFooter\TemplateFooter.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Templates\TemplateSideNav.cfm
0 ms 0 ms 1 D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Templates\TemplateSideNavWithImages.cfm
0 ms  STARTUP, PARSING, COMPILING, LOADING, & SHUTDOWN
62 ms  TOTAL EXECUTION TIME
red = over 250 ms average execution time


Exceptions

14:37:19.019 - Expression Exception - in D:\webfiles\MassMed\WWW\AM\TemplateSection.cfm : line 34
	    Cannot find key April6 in struct.
	    


SQL Queries

GetSystemVariables (Datasource=CFWeb, Time=0ms, Records=90) in D:\webfiles\MassMed\WWW\AM\LoadSessionVariables.cfm @ 14:37:19.019
  SELECT a.*
    FROM System_Variable a
   WHERE VariableTypeCode = 'E'
qSavedBasket (Datasource=CFWeb, Time=0ms, Records=0) in D:\webfiles\MassMed\WWW\AM\Ecommerce\BasketSetupTag.cfm @ 14:37:19.019
    SELECT a.*, 
           b.EtailerID,
           b.SKU,
           b.TaxableFlag,
           b.UnitPrice AS NewPrice,
           b.MemberPrice AS NewMemberPrice,
           b.QuantityEditableFlag,
           c.StockStatusDesc AS StockStatus
      FROM Basket_Save a WITH (NOLOCK),
           Product b WITH (NOLOCK),
           Stock_Status_Ref c WITH (NOLOCK)
     WHERE a.ProductID = b.ProductID
       AND b.StockStatusCode = c.StockStatusCode
       AND 1=0
  
GetHTML (Datasource=CFWeb, Time=31ms, Records=1) in D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\CM\HTMLDisplay.cfm @ 14:37:19.019
    SELECT a.*, b.Keywords, b.Description, b.MembersOnlyFlag
      FROM Content_HTML a, Content b
     WHERE a.ContentID = b.ContentID
       AND a.ContentID = 6278 


Stored Procedures

amsp_CMGetPublishedContentID (Datasource=CFWeb, Time=0ms) in D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\CM\HTMLDisplay.cfm @ 14:37:19.019
    
parameters
typeCFSQLTypevaluevariabledbVarName
 IN  CF_SQL_NUMERIC  6278    
 OUT  CF_SQL_NUMERIC    l_PublishedContentID = l_PublishedContentID  
 IN  CF_SQL_NUMERIC  1    
    
resultsets
nameresultset


Scope Variables

CGI Variables:
AUTH_PASSWORD=
AUTH_TYPE=
AUTH_USER=
CERT_COOKIE=
CERT_FLAGS=
CERT_ISSUER=
CERT_KEYSIZE=
CERT_SECRETKEYSIZE=
CERT_SERIALNUMBER=
CERT_SERVER_ISSUER=
CERT_SERVER_SUBJECT=
CERT_SUBJECT=
CF_TEMPLATE_PATH=D:\webfiles\MASSMED\WWW\AM\Template.cfm
CONTENT_LENGTH=
CONTENT_TYPE=
CONTEXT_PATH=
GATEWAY_INTERFACE=CGI/1.1
HTTPS=off
HTTPS_KEYSIZE=
HTTPS_SECRETKEYSIZE=
HTTPS_SERVER_ISSUER=
HTTPS_SERVER_SUBJECT=
HTTP_ACCEPT=
HTTP_ACCEPT_ENCODING=
HTTP_ACCEPT_LANGUAGE=
HTTP_CONNECTION=
HTTP_COOKIE=
HTTP_HOST=staging1.massmed.org
HTTP_REFERER=
HTTP_USER_AGENT=
PATH_INFO=/AM/Template.cfm
PATH_TRANSLATED=D:\webfiles\MassMed\WWW\AM\Template.cfm
QUERY_STRING=Section=April6&CONTENTID=6278&TEMPLATE=/CM/HTMLDisplay.cfm&FUSEFLAG=1
REMOTE_ADDR=10.1.1.35
REMOTE_HOST=10.1.1.35
REMOTE_USER=
REQUEST_METHOD=GET
SCRIPT_NAME=/AM/Template.cfm
SERVER_NAME=staging1.massmed.org
SERVER_PORT=80
SERVER_PORT_SECURE=0
SERVER_PROTOCOL=HTTP/1.1
SERVER_SOFTWARE=Microsoft-IIS/6.0
WEB_SERVER_API=
Client Variables:
cfid=16490
cftoken=78155519
hitcount=1
lastvisit={ts '2005-02-25 14:37:19'}
timecreated={ts '2005-02-25 14:37:19'}
urltoken=CFID=16490&CFTOKEN=78155519
Request Parameters:
defaultsectionurl=http://staging1.massmed.org/
graphicsdirectory=/AM/graphics/home_template/
l_htmlheadcontentinformation=
  
  
  
    
  
    
  
  
  
  MASSMED | Vital Signs - April 2003
securewebsiterooturl=http://staging1.massmed.org/
websiteindex=5
websitekey=31cadfd9-b130-44b4-af2e-6603cbcc422b
websitekeyvar=31cadfd9_b130_44b4_af2e_6603cbcc422b
websitename=MASSMED
websiterooturl=http://staging1.massmed.org/
Session Variables:
admin=False
administrator=False
adminmicrositeid=0
adminsectionlist=
alldynamic=N
ba=Struct (1)
bannercompanyid=0
bebroadcastemail=Array (0)
bebulkemailauditid=0
bememberid=
bg=Struct (3)
bgcompanyid=0
bgselectionid=0
bgtransactionmode=
browser=Unknown
browserversion=0
candidateid=0
cc=Struct (4)
cdadministratorid=0
cfid=16490
cftoken=78155519
chapter=
cm=Struct (13)
cmbordercolor=#D1CDBB
cmcurrentfolderid=
cmeditorredirecturl=
cmfolderdisplay=
cmfoldersectiondisplay=
cmnavcontentgroupind=
cmsavetemplatepath=
cmsectiondisplay=
cmsuperadminflag=False
cmsurftoeditcontentid=0
cmsurftoeditreturnurl=
cmtextonlytemplate=False
cmwebsitekey=
committee=
companyid=0
companymaster=false
companymembershipnum=
companyname=
contactid=0
coregistrant=Array (0)
cp=Struct (4)
cpemailattachmentlist=
cpinvitationkey=
cpinvitegroupmembers=Array (0)
cpinvitegroupname=
cpinvitegroupsearchcriteria=
ctchapterid=0
customerid=0
cwadministrator=False
debug=False
ec=Struct (6)
eccheckoutprocessstart=false
eccouponnum=
ecshippingmethod=
ecstoreafcheckoutlink=
ecstoreafcheckoutlinkdesc=
eg=Struct (1)
egsubscribedgrouplist=
emailaddress=
faqflag=
firstname=
fontface=verdana
fontsize=2
geformsubmitted=false
headersize=3
imismemberid=
initialized=True
interestcategorylist=
jb=Struct (8)
jbcompany=Struct (0)
jbcompanyname=
jbcoverlettertext=
jbjobid=0
jbpreview=Struct (0)
jbresumesearchflag=false
jbsearch=Struct (0)
lastname=
location=Struct (8)
loggedin=0
mc=Struct (6)
mccurrentmessage=FALSE
mcfirsttime=True
mcmessagetext=
mcprimaryrecipients=
mcsecondaryrecipients=
mcsubject=
md=Struct (1)
mdsearchcriteria=
member=Struct (18)
memberid=0
membershipflag=false
membertype=
message=
ms=Struct (2)
msinitializeprocess=false
msmicrositeadminlist=
mycommittees=
myinterests=
ol=Struct (5)
pe=Struct (2)
platform=Windows
publicresultsflag=
questiondisplaylimit=
recruiterflag=false
recruiterid=0
redirect=
redirectfrom=
registrationpage=
rowcolor1=FFFFFF
rowcolor2=D1DDEA
savedbasket=Query (0)
sb=Struct (1)
sbpresenterid=0
sc=Struct (4)
scadmincomponentcodelist=
screturnmessage=Click here to continue.
scsecuritygroup=
securitygrouplist=
sessionid=CFUSER_16490_78155519
shoppingcart=Array (0)
staff=Struct (13)
su=Struct (8)
supreviewingsurvey=False
surespondingsurveyid=
sureviewingprocess=false
surveydate=
surveyid=0
surveyreporttemplate=
surveyresponse=0
surveyresponseid=0
surveyreviewquestionlist=
surveytakenlist=
surveytype=
susurveyid=0
susurveyresponseid=0
susurveyreviewquestionlist=
susurveytakenlist=
susurveytype=
sy=Struct (21)
templatepath=/AM/Template.cfm?Section=Home
title=
urltoken=CFID=16490&CFTOKEN=78155519
username=
voucheramount=
voucheramountremain=
voucheramountused=
vouchernumber=
URL Parameters:
CONTENTID=6278
FUSEFLAG=1
SECTION=April6
TEMPLATE=/CM/HTMLDisplay.cfm
Debug Rendering Time: 47 ms